Because of the need for the play-off, no Stanley Cup challenges were made against western teams until the following winter. Ottawa had won Stanley Cup challenges that season, which meant that the 1906 season would have two Stanley Cup holders: Ottawa until March, and Montreal Wanderers for the balance of the year.

1906 Regular Season Results

Date    OpponentResultScoreRecord
1/3at Mtl. ShamrocksW  9-3 1-0
1/20vs Ottawa HCL  1-4 1-1
1/31vs Mtl. WanderersL  2-6 1-2
2/7at Mtl. ShamrocksW  4-1 2-2
2/14vs Mtl. WanderersL  2-6 2-3
2/17vs Quebec HCL  6-7
OT
2-4
2/25at Quebec HCW  5-2 3-4
2/28vs Mtl. VictoriasL  5-6 3-5
3/3at Ottawa HCL  9-14 3-6
3/7at Mtl. VictoriasL  6-14 3-7