After losing its three best teams prior to the season, the league was unable to stay relevant, and folded after the 1923-24 season.
First Round
Second Round
NYSL Champ.
GF 1
SCH 0
AMS 1
SCH 0
GF 1
SCH 0
GF 1
AMS 0
COH 1
GF 0
GF 1
COH 0
Champ
GF
z: best record, c: conference winner, y: division winner, w: wildcard, x: clinched playoff spot

First Round

Single game matchup
Round-Robin format.
Date    OpponentResultScoreSeries
???at SchenectadyW  1- 1-0
???at SchenectadyW  1- 2-0

Second Round

Single game matchup
Round-Robin format.
Date    OpponentResultScoreSeries
???vs CohoesL  -1 0-1
???at AmsterdamW  1- 1-1

NYSL Championship

Single game matchup
Round-Robin format.
Date    OpponentResultScoreSeries
???at CohoesW  1- 1-0