Reigning champion Atlantic of Brooklyn and challenger Excelsior of Brooklyn split their first two games. In the third, Excelsior was leading, 8–6, and had men on base, but chose to withdraw because of rowdy behavior by Atlantic partisans and gamblers. The game was declared a draw, and the championship retained by Atlantic.
Historical records of game results and player statistics are missing or incomplete.
Standings were determined by number of total wins, rather than winning percentage. Historical records of game results and player statistics may be missing or incomplete.
|GothamNew York Gotham||8||5||.615||6.5|
|HarlemNew York Harlem||5||2||.714||6.5|
|EagleNew York Eagle||4||4||.500||8.0|
|DetroitDetroit Baseball Club||3||2||.600||7.5|
|PutnamNew York Putnam||3||3||.500||8.0|
|EmpireNew York Empire||3||4||.429||8.5|
|MutualNew York Mutual||1||8||.182||11.5|
|KnicksNew York Knickerbocker||0||1||.000||8.5|
|Bkn. StarBrooklyn Star||0||5||.083||10.5|