By 1867, the association had over 200 teams. Most subpar and short-lived teams are omitted here. Standings were determined by number of total wins, rather than winning percentage. Historical records of game results and player statistics may be missing or incomplete.
TEAMWLPctGB
1867 Philadelphia Athletic LogoAthletic 443.936-
1867 Washington National LogoWashington 297.8069.5
1867 Philadelphia Quaker City LogoPhiladelphia 289.75711.0
1867 New York Mutual LogoMutual 236.78312.0
1867 Morrisania Union LogoUnion   218.72414.0
1867 Brooklyn Atlantic LogoAtlantic 195.78013.5
1867 Philadelphia Geary LogoPhiladelphia 196.76014.0
1867 Boston Tri-Mountain LogoBoston 193.86412.5
1867 Cincinnati Red Stockings LogoCincinnati 171.94412.5
1867 New Jersey Irvington LogoIrvington 167.69616.0
1867 Lansingburgh Union LogoLansingburgh 147.66717.0
1867 Brooklyn Excelsior LogoExcelsior 115.68817.5
1867 Washington Olympic LogoOlympic 115.68817.5
1867 Chicago Excelsior LogoExcelsior 101.90916.0
1867 Boston Lowell LogoLowell 85.61519.0
1867 Cincinnati Buckeye LogoCincinnati 78.46721.0
1867 Brooklyn Eckford LogoEckford 616.28325.5
1867 Brooklyn Star LogoBkn. Star 64.60019.5
1867 Newark Eureka LogoEureka 28.20023.5
1867 New York Eagle LogoEagle 02.00021.5
1867 Albany National LogoAlbany 00.000-
1867 Milwaukee Cream Citys LogoMilwaukee 00.000-
1867 Brooklyn Mohawk LogoMohawk .000-